Meet Our Team

Our leadership’s backgrounds position us as the ideal partner for the niche we serve in the mutual community – from mutual insurers and small insurance carriers to risk retention groups (RRGs), captives, and self-insurance groups – to help launch new products and enter new markets. We invite you to meet the team behind Mutual Underwriters.

Sean Murray

Phone:  317.552.1295

Sean is the former CEO of a Pennsylvania-based mutual insurer and has owned or operated a variety of insurance platforms including a managing general agency, retail agency, RRG and various alternative risk vehicles. He has served in leadership and underwriting positions in these business models.

Scott Piper

Phone: 317.552.1301

Scott is the former President of an Ohio-based mutual insurance company.  He has served in a variety of capacities in his thirty-year career including in claims, underwriting, operations, and leadership at two mutual insurers.

Mark J. Keyser, CPA (Inactive)


Mark is former CFO of a regional group of mutual carriers and former CFO of a $240 million stock insurer. In addition, through his consulting organization, Charter Lane Consulting, he provides financial and strategic advisory services to the mutual community. Mark operates our accounting and billing departments. He is also key advisor in merger and acquisition deals and capital raising opportunities.

On the Path to Our Mutual Success

Mutual Underwriters has extensive executive experience in both the mutual and alternative risk communities. We bring to the table our knowledge, market relationships, and technology savvy in helping others expand their books of business and shape a profitable future. We invite you to find out how we can assist you. Give us a call at 317.552.1189.